The Two Confessions (Dÿ zwu peicht) is an anonymously written story of which the oldest version dates from the second quarter of the 14th century. The manuscript on which this edition and translation are based was composed in the third quarter of the fifteenth century in the region of Northern Bavaria. The story belongs to the genre of “Märe”, i.e. stories handed down anonymously, shaped by literary conventions, aimed at entertainment and without any higher rhetorical, religious or critical claims.

Some context concerning religious practice is in order here. Confession is a sacrament most frequently associated with the Christian faith of Catholicism. In confession, the believer confesses their sins anonymously to a priest, who as an ordained representative of God has the authority to absolve sin and assign penance. In the late Middle Ages, the sacrament of confession worked somewhat differently than in modern Catholicism. It was not anonymous, took place less frequently, and there was a kind of “emergency provision” for confessing to a lay person (someone who is not clergy). It is also worth noting that in the Middle Ages, priests were always men.

The Two Confessions tells the story of a husband and wife who decide to confess their sins to one another. The wife initiates the process and is the first to confess; her husband’s question of whether she has had any other man leads her to confess to having slept with a total of twelve men in the village: the young shepherd, the lord’s messenger, the priest, the judge, the cellarer, the lord’s cook, the old shepherd, the neighbour’s son and three of his companions, and finally the sacristan. Against the husband’s complaints about her infidelity, the wife explains that each affair was to the advantage of their household: sleeping with the shepherd in lieu of making the traditional small payment for services, the lord’s messenger will take them under his protection, the cellarer and the cook provide them food and drink, and so on. Accepting his wife’s reasoning, the husband forgives her, and it is then his turn to confess. The husband confesses to having taken pleasure from touching their maid’s hand while they were on the field together. For this, the wife demands as penance that he cut off his hand and undertake a pilgrimage to Rome. She argues that her actions were borne out of wanting to provide for their household and good standing, whereas his indiscretion was purely out of lust for the maid. The husband pleads with his wife for mercy, until she instructs him to lead his life more truthfully going forward and then, assuming the role traditionally reserved for a male priest, uses Latin to absolve him of sin.

The modern reader may appreciate the entertaining and comical depiction of married life in the German Middle Ages through reading The Two Confessions. The story is quite literally a “he said, she said”: a man and a woman offer contradictory explanations of the same event with the reader being presented only with the spoken exchange and no kind of description. This simplistic yet direct style draws in readers, who might find themselves impressed by the extravagance of the wife’s confession and her subsequent furor at her husband having touched the maid’s hand. Gender, power, and the hierarchy of German society in the late Middle Ages all interrelate with each other in The Two Confessions.

The Two Confessions survives in five manuscripts dating from the fourteenth to the mid-fifteenth century: Berlin, Staatsbibliothek Preuβischer Kulturbesitz, Ms. germ. oct. 1430 (B), Karlsruhe, Badische Landesbibliothek, Karlsruhe 408 (K), Donaueschingen 104, (Do), Vienna (Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Cod. 3027 (W), and Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, cgm 714 (M), which is the text transcribed and translated here.

Because the versions of The Two Confessions in these five manuscripts differ to varying degrees from one another, scholars have divided them into two distinct groupings: Die zwei Beichten A (versions Do, K, W, and B) and Die zwei Beichten B (version M). Version M, the one presented here, is distinct in its setting, the role of the spouses, the number of lovers and the reason for the affairs. In Die Zwei Beichten A, the story is set at Easter. The couple is snowed in, preventing them from doing their yearly confession to a priest, which prompts the husband to suggest they confess to each other. This setting is absent in M, where the wife proposes the confession time while sitting at the fire. In M, the story ends with the wife taking on the role of the priest and, after a tongue-lashing, grants the husband absolution, whereas in the other versions the husband gets beaten with a broom. In some versions (Do and K), the story ends with a moral, either asking God to shame “false wives” (Do) or advising husbands not to ask questions of their wives that they don’t want to know the answer to (K). The number of lovers in M is high (12) as compared to Do (4) and K (5), but not as high as in version W (21). However, the motivation for having slept with them in M is only economical; in the other versions there are a variety of reasons besides economical gain: violence, lust, pity.

Die zwei Beichten is titled Dÿ zwu peicht and appears in cgm 714, on fol. 431r-441v, which is housed in the Bayerischen Staatsbibliothek München (Bavarian State Library in Munich). With its 204 lines, it is one of the longer versions of this tale. The manuscript is dated to the third quarter of the 15th century and was written in Nordbairisch (a North-Bavarian variety of Middle High German) on paper. Cgm 714 is a compilation manuscript that contains rhymed couplet texts largely belonging to the genres of Minnerede (texts about love), Mären (comic tales) and Fastnachtsspiele (carnival plays).

“Die zwei Beichten A.” In Deutsche Versnovellistick des 13. bis 15. Jahrhunderts, edited by Klaus Ridder and Hans-Joachim Ziegeler, 112–30. Schwabe Verlag, 2020.

Fischer, H. Die deutsche Märendichtung des 15. Jahrhunderts. Münchener Texte und Untersuchungen zur Deutschen Literatur des Mittelalters. Beck, 1966. https://books.google.ca/books?id=fuYfAQAAIAAJ.

Rasmussen, Ann Marie. “Gender und Subjektivität im Märe die zwei Beichten (A und B).” edited by Martin Baisch, Jutta Eming, Hendrikje Haufe, and Andrea Sieber, 271–87. Ulrike Helmer Verlag, 2005.

Schneider, Karin. “cgm 714: Minnereden • Mären • Fastnachtsspiele.” In Die deutschen Handschriften der Bayerischen Staatsbibliothek München: cgm 691-867, Altera., 79–89. Otto Harrassowitz, 1984. daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/0010/bsb00106375/images/index.html?id=00106375&groesser=&fip=193.174.98.30&no=&seite=81.

Schröder, Werner. “Die zwei Beichten A und die zwei Beichten B.” In Die deutsche Literatur des Mittelalters. Verfasserlexikon, 2nd ed., 1615–17. Verfasserlexikon 10. Berlin, 1977ff.